MINNESOTA

Barley Rusts in the United States in 1997

D.L. Long1, B.J. Steffenson2, K.J. Leonard1, M.E. Hughes1 and D.H. Casper1
1Cereal Disease Laboratory, USDA-ARS and 2Department of
Plant Pathology, North Dakota State University


Stem rust (Puccinia graminis f. sp. tritici). In 1997, traces of barley stem rust were first found in barley plots in southern Texas at Beeville on May 19. Limited amounts of barley are grown commercially in the southern states and stem rust rarely occurs on barley in this area. Barley stem rust was next reported in mid-July, where traces of the pathogen were found on spring barleys in east central South Dakota plots. Less barley stem rust was found in the northern plains this year than in recent years because nearly all barley cultivars are resistant to the predominant stem rust race TPMK. Race QCCJ, which infects barley cultivars with the resistance gene Rpg1, was not found in the U.S. in 1997. The lack of QCCJ may be due to the reduced acreage of winter wheat cultivars susceptible to this race in Kansas. Only three barley stem rust collections were received at the Cereal Disease Laboratory in 1997. Six of the nine isolates from these collections were identified as race QCCS (an older race not in the same lineage as QCCJ), the other three were TPMK.

Losses to barley stem rust were light in 1997 (Table 1).

Leaf rust (Puccinia hordei). During the first week in April, leaf rust severities of trace to 10% were observed on the lower leaves of barley in southern and central Texas plots. Trace rust severities were observed in barley plots in the Southern San Joaquin Valley of California (Merced County) and in the Yuma, Arizona area. Rust severities from 10-40% developed on barley in this region of California by mid-May and in Virginia, traces of leaf rust were found in barley nurseries.

In late May, light amounts of barley leaf rust were reported in south central Pennsylvania and in the Skagit Valley of western Washington on winter barleys. By the second week in June, barley leaf rust was moderate to severe, and in early July, it was severe on susceptible fall-planted and spring-planted cultivars in the varietal plots in the Skagit Valley.

In mid-July, leaf rust severities of trace to 40% were observed in barley plots in west central Minnesota and northeastern South Dakota; however, no leaf rust was found in commercial fields. Leaf rust developed relatively late on barley in North Dakota. In mid-August, leaf rust severities ranged from trace to 25% in commercial fields in north central North Dakota. At Langdon, some late maturing lines had a rust severity of 60% in early September.

Twelve differential barley genotypes were used to identify races of P. hordei (Table 2). These races were designated according to a system similar to that of Roelfs and Martens (Phytopathology 78:526-533) as shown in Table 3. Ten races of barley leaf rust were identified from 24 collections in 1997 (Table 4). The most common races were race RHD (20%, Arizona and North Dakota), MCD (20%, California, North Dakota, and Virginia), and MCJ (14%, North Dakota). These results are similar to those observed in 1996, where races RHD and MCJ were most common.

In 1997, losses to barley leaf rust were light in the U.S. (Table 1).

Stripe rust (Puccinia striiformis f. sp. hordei). In early March, ôhot spots ô of barley stripe rust were observed in nurseries and variety strip tests on the UC Davis agronomy farm in Davis California. By the first week of April, barley stripe rust was severe on the Davis campus and Yolo county plots in California. During the second week in April, barley stripe rust was present in light to severe amounts in commercial fields in the San Joaquin Valley of California. In some fields, the infections were lighter than in 1996, but in other fields, 20% severities were observed on flag leaves. Barley stripe rust appeared to increase even under dry conditions. During late April, barley stripe rust was widespread in CaliforniaÆs fall-sown spring barley crop. Some advanced lines that exhibited low rust severities last season were susceptible in 1997. Many of the commercial cultivars are extremely susceptible to stripe rust, while UC 603 exhibited a high level of tolerance. By early July, stripe rust on barley was appearing on spring-sown barley in the intermountain area of northeastern California. Severities of 80-100% were reported in northeastern California nurseries, and in commercial fields 100% severities were reported on flag leaves at the milk stage of development. Many fields in this area were sprayed with Folicur to control the rust. Except for northeastern California, total crop damage was less than in 1996, since stripe rust onset was late this season and crop development was earlier.

In early March, barley stripe rust was found in winter barley plots at Corvallis, Oregon. By late March, stripe rust pustules were found at low levels in susceptible cultivars within a 16 m diameter circle of the original infected plots, and by mid-April, barley was heavily infected with stripe rust in winter trial plots at Corvallis. During the last two weeks of April, cool, wet weather slowed stripe rust development in winter barley plots, but in late May, barley stripe rust was increasing in spring barley plots at Corvallis.

In late April, stripe rust severities of 20% were reported on the lower leaves of winter barley growing in the Skagit Valley of western Washington, and by late May the rust was severe. By the first week in July, barley stripe rust was severe on susceptible fall-planted and spring-planted cultivars growing in varietal plots in the Skagit Valley. In early July, light amounts of barley stripe rust were detected in the Palouse region of Washington and Idaho.

In mid-July, severities of 70% were observed in spring barley test plots in west central Idaho, while traces were found in the northern tip of Idaho. Since the plants were in an advanced plant growth stage, the rust did not significantly affect the yield.

Barley stripe rust is now firmly established in California and the Pacific Northwest, where the climate is most favorable for its development. Losses to barley stripe rust occurred in fields throughout California and the Pacific Northwest. In 1997, 20, 4, 0.5 and 0.1% losses to barley stripe rust occurred in California, Oregon, Washington and Idaho, respectively (Table 1).

Crown rust (Puccinia coronata). In mid-June, crown rust severities of up to 15% were observed on barley lines growing 15 meters from Rhamnus plants in a nursery at Casselton, North Dakota. Barley crown rust was found in several commercial fields in trace amounts in the Red River Valley region in mid-August. Crown rust reached 80% severity on susceptible barley cultivars planted in an east central South Dakota nursery. Losses in barley to crown rust were negligible in 1997.
 

Table 1. Estimated losses in barley due to rust in 1997
Losses due to 
1000
Yield in
Production,
Stem 
Rust
Leaf 
Rust Stripe Rust 
acres
bushels
1000
1000
1000
1000
State
harvested
per acre
bushels
%
bushels
%
bushels
%
bushels 
AZ
67
102.5
6,834
0
0
0
0
0
0
CA
180
55
9,900
0
0
1
125
20
2506
CO
90
112
10,080
0
0
*T
T
0
0
ID
760
79
60,040
0
0
0.1
60
0.1
60
KS
8
40
320
0
0
0
0
KY
14
75
1,050
0
0
T
T
MI
24
60
1,440
0
0
0
0
MN
540
51
27,540
T
T
T
T
MT
1,200
53
63,600
0
0
0
0
0
0
NE
8
51
408
0
0
0
0
NC
20
70
1,400
0
0
5
74
ND
2,250
45
101,250
T
T
T
T
OK
8
42
336
0
0
0
0
OR
120
69
8,280
0.1
9
2
176
4
353
PA
75
68
5,100
0
0
T
T
SC
3
60
180
0
0
1
2
SD
130
38
4,940
T
T
T
T
TX
5
47
235
0
0
0
0
0
0
UT
95
86
8,170
0
0
0
0
VA
65
85
5,525
0
0
T
T
WA
490
76
37,240
0.2
75
0.1
38
0.5
188
WI
65
55
3,575
0
0
0
0
WY
115
80
9,200
0
0
0
0
Total
6,332
366,643
75
475
3107
Average
57.9
0.02
0.13
0.84
U.S.
6,425
58.3
374,478
*T = Trace

Table 2. Barley genotypes used to differentiate isolates of Puccinia hordei
Genotype Resistance gene(s)
Sudan
Rph1
Peruvian
Rph2
Estate
Rph3
Gold
Rph4
Magnif
Rph5
Bolivia
Rph6+2
Cebada Capa
Rph7
Egypt 4
Rph8
Hor 2596
Rph9
Clip BC8
Rph10
Clip BC67
Rph11
Triumph
Rph12

 

Table 3. A proposed North American system of pathotype nomenclature for Puccinia hordei based on 12 differential barley hostsa Infection phenotype of pathogen and barley Rph genes
Set 1 Rph1 Rph2 Rph3 Rph4
Set 2 Rph5 Rph6+2 Rph7 Rph8
Set 3 Rph9 Rph10 Rph11 Rph12
Ph-code
B Low Low Low Low
C Low Low Low High
D Low Low High Low
F Low Low High High
G Low High Low Low
H Low High Low High
J Low High High Low
K Low High High High
L High Low Low Low
M High Low Low High
N High Low High Low
P High Low High High
Q High High Low Low
R High High Low High
S High High High Low
T High High High High
a Pathotype designations are based on the infection phenotypes of the pathogen isolate on the 12 differential barley hosts. Low = incompatibility (infection phenotypes 0, 0;, 1, or 2) and High = compatibility (infection phenotypes 3 or 4). The infection phenotypes from set 1 determine the first letter of the code, those from set 2 the second letter, etc.
 

Table 4. Races of Puccinia hordei identified from the United States in 1997
Number of
State collections Source Pathotypes and (number of collections)
Arizona
1
Nursery RHD(1)
Arkansas
1
Nursery
California
5
Nursery RHB(1), RCB(1), RBB(1),MBD(1), MCD(1)
Minnesota
3
Nursery RHJ(1)
North Dakota
8
Field MCJ(2), RHD(2), MBB(1), MCD(1)
Pennsylvania
1
Field
South Dakota
3
Nursery MHD(1)
Tennesee
1
Field
Virginia
1
Nursery MCD(1)
TOTAL
15 a
a - nine collections produced no infection and were classified as dead.